Why Landlords Should Require Renters Insurance

5 mins read
Why Landlords Should Require Renters Insurance

Landlord insurance protects your property, but it doesn’t cover your tenant’s belongings or their personal liability. Requiring renters insurance fills the gap. In this article, we’ll break down the difference between landlord insurance and renters insurance, explain how the two policies complement each other, and why requiring renters insurance is a smart and low-friction way to protect your rental business.

What Is Landlord Insurance?

Landlord insurance (also known as rental property insurance) is designed to protect your investment property. It typically includes:

  • Dwelling coverage – for the structure itself
  • Loss of rental income – if the unit becomes uninhabitable due to a covered peril
  • Landlord liability – if you’re found legally responsible for injury or property damage

What it doesn’t cover is anything your tenant owns—or many of the risks caused by tenant behavior.

What Is Renters Insurance?

Renters insurance is purchased by the tenant. It usually includes:

  • Personal property coverage – for belongings damaged or stolen
  • Liability coverage – if the tenant accidentally causes harm or damage
  • Loss of use – covers temporary living expenses if the unit becomes unlivable

The Coverage Gap: Why One Policy Isn’t Enough

Here’s where things often get misunderstood. Some landlords assume their policy is enough. But in reality:

  • If a fire destroys your rental, your policy replaces the walls—not the tenant’s couch.
  • If a tenant’s dog bites someone, your liability coverage may be dragged in—unless they have their own.
  • If a kitchen flood destroys downstairs units due to tenant negligence, you might face legal complications without a tenant’s renters policy in place.

Renters insurance fills these coverage gaps and makes liability clearer.

Side-by-Side Comparison: Landlord Insurance vs. Renters Insurance

To understand the difference more clearly, here’s a comparison table that shows who is protected by what and what gaps exist if renters insurance is not in place:

Coverage Area Landlord Insurance Renters Insurance Who It Protects
Structure / Building ✅ Yes ❌ No Landlord
Tenant's Personal Belongings ❌ No ✅ Yes Tenant
Personal Liability (Tenant) ❌ No ✅ Yes Tenant
Landlord's Liability ✅ Yes ❌ No Landlord
Temporary Housing (Tenant) ❌ No ✅ Yes Tenant
Damage from Tenant Negligence ✅ Sometimes (may result in higher premiums) ✅ Yes (tenant’s liability covers landlord losses) Both parties
Fire / Water Damage ✅ Building repairs only ✅ Tenant’s items only Landlord (structure), Tenant (items)
Required by Law ✅ Usually required by mortgage lender ❌ Not required by law (landlord must request) Varies

Why Landlords Should Require Renters Insurance

Requiring renters insurance is a growing trend among property managers and for good reason:

1. Reduce Your Liability Exposure

Tenants with renters insurance can cover personal liability claims that might otherwise involve your landlord policy. This includes injuries, fires, or water damage caused by their negligence.

2. Prevent Disputes After Damage

If a tenant’s belongings are damaged and they lack coverage, they may wrongly assume you’re responsible. Renters insurance makes clear who covers what, reducing conflict and confusion.

frustration on lease agreement

3. Screen for Responsibility

A tenant who’s willing to get renters insurance often signals they’re financially responsible and take tenancy seriously. It’s an easy screening filter.

4. Cost Is Low for Tenants

Renters insurance typically costs between $12–$18/month. It’s affordable and easy to buy online—making it a low-friction requirement.

5. Protect Against Tenant-Caused Loss

If a tenant accidentally starts a fire or causes water damage, their liability coverage can reimburse your costs—before your policy has to step in.

How to Enforce It

Many landlords now include renters insurance as a lease requirement. To do this:

  • Add a clause in the lease agreement requiring active renters insurance.
  • Ask for proof of coverage before move-in.
  • Require policy to name you as an “interested party” (so you get notified if it’s canceled).

Final Thoughts

Landlord insurance is essential, but it has limits. Requiring renters insurance doesn’t just protect your tenants—it protects you. It ensures that property damage, legal liability, and temporary housing needs don’t fall solely on your shoulders.

In a high-risk rental environment, adding this one simple requirement can be one of the most cost-effective risk management tools available to landlords today.

Find your perfect insurance policy

Compare the top insurance brands at once for free